Would love to see someone go for 10 of these!

I do anal on the first date

His ex’s said 8.5 was too big for anal, so I had to try it… now we’re both hooked

This is my new record!

Best birth control ever

I love stretching my butt just like that

Since I’m not allowed to post these on that one website anymore 😔

[Self] First time for everything? And loved it.

(OC) my first time! My ass is so tight . Ended up fitting 8!

Pretty sure this is over 40, not sharpies though [OC]

In her final appearance I present a new record, 23 sharpies!

First time posting, won't be the last.

8 on the first try!

New record of [f]our from work today;)

Wi(f)e wanted to try the magnum sharpies, next time she says she wants to see how many regular sharpies will fit with these

I could only find one which is boring but the angle looks great!

I was trying to be productive, then my new “King Size” Sharpie came in the mail. Played with my ass instead. No regrets.

[s] Up to 17 for Sir

I definitely liked the feel of the double penetration. However, the Sharpie Magnum did not slide in easy 😬😍. But what can I say, I’m just a sucker for pain.

First Challenge - My friend told me 14 was the record and 15 seemed stupidly easy 😋 Guess I’ve got to go for 24!

I asked my girlfriend if I could fill her ass, she said yes.. 7 is a great start!

10 on the first try

[self] 14 sharpies. Working up to getting my fist in my asshole.

Lots of grip on the large suction cup dildo